Sep 24·Geo
Follow-up 3h ago4
83%
New York sues Polymarket over unlicensed gambling, defying federal regulators
New York sued Polymarket on September 24, 2026, claiming it operates an unlicensed gambling platform that evades taxes and targets minors. The lawsuit seeks to shut down Polymarket's operations in the state and impose penalties, marking the second major enforcement action against prediction markets following New York's suit against Kalshi.
Quick Facts
- New York filed a lawsuit against Polymarket alleging unlicensed gambling operation
- State claims Polymarket evades gaming license requirements and state taxes
- State alleges Polymarket allows betting by users aged 18–20, below New York's 21-year minimum for mobile sports betting
- State seeks court order to stop Polymarket operations, impose fines up to three times illegal gains, and require user restitution
- Polymarket claims it operates financial contracts similar to stock markets, not gambling


New York filed a lawsuit against Polymarket on Thursday, September 24, 2026, alleging the prediction market platform operates as an unlicensed gambling business in violation of state law. Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James argue that Polymarket circumvents required gaming licenses, avoids state taxes that fund public schools and gambling treatment programs, and exposes minors aged 18–20 to betting despite New York's 21-year-old minimum for mobile sports betting.
The state is seeking a court order to halt Polymarket's operations in New York, impose financial penalties up to three times the company's alleged illegal gains, and require restitution to users. This lawsuit is the second major enforcement action New York has taken against prediction markets, following a similar suit against Kalshi in July. Both cases reflect a state-level effort to regulate platforms that have operated in a legal gray area, with prediction market companies arguing they offer financial contracts—not gambling—and that the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission holds exclusive jurisdiction.
Polymarket's Chief Legal Officer Neal Kumar stated the company will defend itself in court, emphasizing that Polymarket was founded in New York, now employs 350 people there, and remains committed to the state. The company contends its business model differs from traditional gambling: consumers trade contracts against each other based on event outcomes, similar to stock markets, with the platform taking only a trading fee.
The dispute reflects a broader jurisdictional conflict. The CFTC has opposed state regulation of prediction markets and asserted federal authority. In August, the CFTC declared a "market emergency" in New York to attempt to block the state's enforcement against Kalshi. However, federal appeals courts have issued conflicting rulings: a New Jersey court ruled states cannot regulate Kalshi, while a Nevada court allowed state gambling regulations to apply to Kalshi's contracts. This legal uncertainty has not deterred New York's enforcement efforts.
Why This Matters
New York's enforcement action against Polymarket creates immediate operational risk for the platform's users and business in the state, affecting an estimated 350 local employees and potentially millions in disputed trading volumes. The lawsuit's outcome will determine whether state gambling law applies to prediction markets or whether federal CFTC jurisdiction prevails—a legal conflict with precedent split across state courts. Tax and licensing disputes directly impact state revenue funding public schools and addiction treatment; federal-state regulatory uncertainty may reshape how US-based prediction market platforms structure operations.
Timeline & Sources
Sep 24, 2026
WireNew York sues Polymarket, alleging unlicensed gambling operation and seeking court order to halt operations
Sources
- Polymarket New York Lawsuit Gambling B75b753e3c3cd069cdf8d6af175c9fbbapWireSep 24, 2026
- New York defies Trump admin, asks court to shut down Polymarket gamblingars_technicaMediaSep 24, 2026
- New York sues prediction market Polymarket, calling it an unlicensed gambling operationcp24.comMediaSep 24, 2026
- New York sues Polymarket over unlicensed gambling operation just as it did rival Kalshitechspot.comMediaSep 26, 2026