England's World Cup Ambitions: Experts Expect Semi-Final Push Under Tuchel

Thomas Tuchel was appointed England head coach at the end of 2024 with a clear mandate: to end the nation's 60-year drought without a major international men's football trophy. As England prepares to open their World Cup campaign against Croatia, multiple expert analysts have assessed the team's prospects and chances in the tournament.

Expectations among observers are notably high. Several experts, including Jay Harris, argue that anything less than reaching the semi-finals would constitute a failure, reflecting the raised standards set by predecessor Gareth Southgate. Jack Pitt-Brooke forecasts England will reach the semi-finals, likely exiting to Argentina or Portugal in Atlanta. This optimism is grounded in England's exceptional midfield spine, with Declan Rice and Harry Kane identified as among the world's best players in recent years. England's perfect qualifying record and Tuchel's reputation as a tactically accomplished coach further bolster confidence.

However, concerns persist about the squad's composition and tactical approach. Oliver Kay questions Tuchel's omission of several technically gifted players including Trent Alexander-Arnold, Adam Wharton, Phil Foden, and Cole Palmer—all players representative of a new generation of technically skilled English footballers. Kay argues that Tuchel's emphasis on pace and energy may not optimally leverage this generation's strengths, particularly in a physically demanding North American summer tournament. Pitt-Brooke shares concerns about potential shortcomings in the final third, particularly regarding England's historical dependence on Kane and whether the squad might lack creative solutions if the striker faces any restriction.

The squad selection reflects a more direct, physical style prioritising set pieces over technical creativity. While experts acknowledge the strength of England's overall squad composition and coaching, questions remain about whether Tuchel's tactical philosophy fully exploits the nation's most talented players, particularly those omitted from the squad.